Compare renting and buying over your chosen horizon, including mortgage, ownership costs, sale proceeds and investment of the difference.
NEWCOMER PLANNING WORKSPACE General information only
Rent or buy a home in Spain?
Compare renting and buying over your chosen horizon, including mortgage, ownership costs, sale proceeds and investment of the difference.
Your rent vs buy comparison
Enter your figures or load the labelled example, then compare both options.
How the comparison is calculated
Both paths start with the same capital: the larger of the buyer’s upfront cash and the renter’s deposit plus entry costs. Each invests any unused remainder. Each month both receive the same housing budget, equal to the more expensive path’s outflow that month; the cheaper path invests the difference at month-end. Portfolios earn the entered net annual return converted to a monthly effective rate. The fixed-rate mortgage uses monthly amortisation, with the final payment adjusted to clear the balance. At every year-end the model assumes a sale: the buyer keeps sale proceeds after entered fees, tax budget and outstanding debt, plus investments; the renter keeps investments plus the fully returned deposit. Values are nominal euros, not inflation-adjusted.
Purchase and sale taxes need a separate check
Enter your confirmed purchase-tax total in euros. New and used homes can follow different tax regimes and regional conditions. Mortgage formalisation costs and purchase costs are different: do not charge lender-paid mortgage costs to yourself. Use the property purchase calculator to prepare the tax budget, then transfer the total once. Sale tax is a user-entered reserve, not an automatic capital-gains calculation; include relevant municipal tax and mortgage-closing costs in the appropriate exit fields.
What this model leaves to you
No mortgage approval, variable-rate forecast, rent-increase entitlement, investment guarantee, tax exemption or future home valuation is inferred. Rent growth is a scenario input, not a statement of a legal rent cap. Sale proceeds can be negative if debt and costs exceed value. The fixed sale-tax reserve is reused at every year-end; actual tax depends on the exit and your circumstances. The deposit is assumed fully returned and renovation does not automatically increase resale value. Monthly costs and returns are rounded to cents. The comparison assumes the higher monthly housing budget is affordable and the cheaper path actually invests the difference; it does not test household affordability.
Calculator at a glance
Compare renting and buying over your chosen horizon, including mortgage, ownership costs, sale proceeds and investment of the difference.
What you enter
Home price, comparable rent, comparison period, fixed-rate mortgage, purchase and ownership costs, deposits, sale costs, tax budget and growth and savings-return assumptions.
What you get
Year-by-year net position for renting and buying, housing outflows, investment balances, net sale value and any modeled crossing year.
Keep in mind
Both paths use equal starting capital and monthly budgets, investing the difference. Results depend on your assumptions and do not forecast prices, legal rent increases, mortgage approval or household affordability.
Both paths start with the same capital: the larger of the buyer’s upfront cash and the renter’s deposit plus entry costs. Each invests any unused remainder. Each month both receive the same housing budget, equal to the more expensive path’s outflow that month; the cheaper path invests the difference at month-end. Portfolios earn the entered net annual return converted to a monthly effective rate. The fixed-rate mortgage uses monthly amortisation, with the final payment adjusted to clear the balance. At every year-end the model assumes a sale: the buyer keeps sale proceeds after entered fees, tax budget and outstanding debt, plus investments; the renter keeps investments plus the fully returned deposit. Values are nominal euros, not inflation-adjusted.
No mortgage approval, variable-rate forecast, rent-increase entitlement, investment guarantee, tax exemption or future home valuation is inferred. Rent growth is a scenario input, not a statement of a legal rent cap. Sale proceeds can be negative if debt and costs exceed value. The fixed sale-tax reserve is reused at every year-end; actual tax depends on the exit and your circumstances. The deposit is assumed fully returned and renovation does not automatically increase resale value. Monthly costs and returns are rounded to cents. The comparison assumes the higher monthly housing budget is affordable and the cheaper path actually invests the difference; it does not test household affordability.
Worked examples
With a zero loan, mortgage interest and setup costs are zero. Buying still requires purchase taxes, ownership costs and exit assumptions.
If buying costs more each month, the renter invests the difference. After the mortgage ends, the buyer may instead have more monthly cash to invest.
Examples are illustrative. Read the assumptions and limitations before using a result.
Common questions
Does the crossing year guarantee buying is better?
No. It is an annual comparison under your inputs. A first crossing can reverse. The sustained year only covers the remaining years within your selected horizon, not every future year.
Is mortgage principal an expense that disappears?
No. Mortgage cash payments affect the monthly budget, but repaid principal reduces debt and is reflected in sale equity. It is not deducted a second time as a lost cost.